30

Listed Now

$22,661

Avg. Asking Price

1967–1999

Year Range

Transmission Distribution

Automatic 80% ◄

Manual 13%

Condition Distribution

Excellent 3%

Good 7%

Fair 7%

Poor 3%

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

✓

Cougar rust patterns mirror Mustang patterns since the cars share platform. The torque boxes (front and rear, where unibody meets floor pans) are structural killers. Cowl rust hides under the dashboard where the windshield base meets the firewall. Floor pans rust through from underneath. Rear quarters, lower fenders behind front wheels, and trunk drop-offs are universal rust zones. The 1971-1973 cars (larger Big Body proportions) have additional rust concerns at the rear shock towers. Mechanically, Mercury Cougars used Ford engines: 289 (1967), 302 (1968-1973), 351W (1969-1973), 351C (1970-1973), 390 (1968), 427 (1968 GT-E), 428 Cobra Jet (1968-1970), Boss 302 (1969-1970 Eliminator). All are bulletproof when maintained. Common issues include broken motor mounts on big-block cars, worn timing chains, leaky valve covers and oil pan gaskets, and tired Holley or Autolite carburetors. The Toploader four-speed manual is bulletproof. The C4 and C6 automatics are robust but commonly leak from front pump seals. The 9-inch Ford rear axle is essentially indestructible. Electrical issues are universal classic-car concerns. The original wiring harnesses are 50+ years old and prone to chafing. Headlight switches and ignition switches commonly fail. The hidden headlight system on 1967-1970 Cougars uses vacuum actuators that fail when vacuum lines crack — common issue on neglected cars. Shock tower cracks on Big Block cars (390, 427, 428 CJ) are a known issue. Cracks radiating from the upper shock mount indicate a beaten chassis common on hard-driven Cougars.

Marti Report is the gold-standard verification for any 1967-and-later Cougar. Marti Auto Works has Ford's exclusive licensed access to original 1967-2007 production records. The Marti Report ($25 basic, more for elite) confirms original engine, transmission, axle ratio, paint, and options. Mandatory for any premium-trim claim. For GT-E claims (1968 only), demand specialist authentication. Only 394 GT-E Cougars were produced across two model years (357 cars in 1968 with 427 V8, 37 cars in 1969 with 428 Cobra Jet V8). Every chassis number is documented in the marque registry. For Eliminator claims (1969-1970 only), verify the unique Eliminator paint color (Bright Yellow, Competition Orange, Bright Blue, Pastel Blue, Bright Green, Wimbledon White, Vermilion) and graphics package via Marti Report. The Eliminator package was offered with multiple engine options including the rare Boss 302 and 428 Cobra Jet. Engine verification is essential. The 5th digit of the VIN identifies the engine code. Cross-reference against the engine block casting number. The most desirable engines: 390 GT (1968), 427 V8 (1968 GT-E only), 428 Cobra Jet (1968-1970), 428 SCJ Ram Air (1969-1970), Boss 302 (1969-1970 Eliminator only). Unibody integrity is the second non-negotiable. Pop the hood and look at the shock towers — cracks radiating from the upper shock mount are common on Big Block cars. Inspect torque boxes (front and rear) from underneath. Lift the trunk mat and look at the trunk drop-offs. Pull the rear seat and check the floor where the seat bolts down. For 1967-1970 cars with hidden headlights, test the headlight system through full open and close cycle. Failed vacuum actuators are common on neglected cars. Document the car. Photograph every panel, every chassis number stamping, every engine bay component, every dataplate, and every identifying tag. Order Marti Report before negotiating final price.

1967-1968 first-generation Cougars: driver-quality 289/302 V8 cars run $22,000-$42,000. Documented original cars: $35,000-$55,000. The 1967 launch year is more desirable than 1968. 1968 Cougar XR-7 GT (with 390 GT V8): driver-quality cars run $32,000-$58,000. Documented numbers-matching cars: $48,000-$80,000. 1968-1969 Cougar GT-E (only 394 total produced): driver-quality cars run $70,000-$130,000. Documented numbers-matching cars: $90,000-$160,000+. The 1968 427 V8 GT-E is the most desirable variant. 1969-1970 Cougar Eliminator: driver-quality cars run $35,000-$70,000. Documented Eliminators with the Boss 302 or 428 CJ: $60,000-$120,000+. Eliminator with 351W or 351C: $42,000-$80,000. 1969-1970 Cougar XR-7 (base XR-7 trim): driver-quality cars run $25,000-$50,000. Documented original cars: $38,000-$65,000. 1971-1973 Cougar (larger Big Body proportions): driver-quality cars run $18,000-$38,000. The 1973 Cougar XR-7 is the most desirable variant of this era. Convertible Cougars (1969-1973 only) command 25-35% premium over equivalent hardtops. Documented 1969-1970 Cougar Eliminator convertibles (extremely rare) command 50-75% premium. Project Cougars start around $10,000-$22,000 across most years. Stripped roller candidates: $5,000-$12,000.

The Mercury Cougar launched for 1967 as the Mercury counterpart to the Ford Mustang — sharing platform and drivetrains but featuring distinctive Mercury styling. The Cougar's hidden headlights with sequential turn signals were Mercury's deliberate styling differentiation from the Mustang. The longer 111-inch wheelbase (versus Mustang's 108 inches) provided more interior space and a more refined ride. The Cougar received Motor Trend's "Car of the Year" award for 1967 — significant recognition for a launch-year vehicle. The 1968 Cougar GT-E was Mercury's response to the Shelby GT350/GT500 — a low-production high-performance package designed to elevate the Cougar's performance image. Total GT-E production was only 394 cars, all in 1968 (357 with the 427 V8 and 37 with the 428 Cobra Jet V8). The GT-E was Mercury's most exclusive performance Cougar of the entire first-generation production run, and documented original GT-E cars now command $80,000-$160,000+ at auction. The 1969-1970 Cougar Eliminator was Mercury's answer to the Mustang Boss series. The Eliminator package featured distinctive paint colors specifically chosen to be eye-catching on dragstrips and at car shows: Bright Yellow, Competition Orange, Bright Blue, and Vermilion. Engine options included the legendary Boss 302 (which homologated the engine for SCCA Trans-Am racing) and the 428 Cobra Jet. Mercury produced approximately 9,000 Eliminators across two model years — making them rare but more accessible than GT-E variants.