Humpty Dumpty's Classics

Humpty Dumpty's Classics is a Sarasota, Florida dealer that sells muscle cars, customized El Caminos, classic trucks and a mix of other collector vehicles. We found no working website of its own, so its inventory is found through online classified sites such as ClassicCars.com and Hemmings. It is an independent business and is not affiliated with Classic Cars Arena.

Who they are

BBB lists the business as a Sarasota corporation with 29 years in business, and it gives April 1997 as the start date. That is a registration-style date, so we treat it as a rough guide to age and not as a founding year. We did not find an owner's name, a company history or a mission statement. We found no valid website for the business, so we do not link to one.

What it sells

The ClassicCars.com dealer page showed 70 vehicles on October 23, 2026, and Hemmings showed 72. Most of the examples we saw are American cars and trucks from the 1950s through the 1980s. Examples on ClassicCars.com included a 1969 AMC AMX Go-Pack at $50,000, a 1967 Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme convertible at $39,900, a 1974 Dodge Dart Sport at $39,900, a 1972 Plymouth Duster 360 at $39,900, a 1955 Ford Thunderbird at $37,900 and a 1957 Chevrolet 3100 pickup at $44,900. Several El Camino listings from 1980 to 1986 were described as customized or tribute builds, priced from about $22,900 to $49,500.

The dealer also lists vehicles that are not classics, including a 2012 Jeep Wrangler, a Harley-Davidson motorcycle and, on Hemmings, cars such as a 2004 Mercedes-Benz 500SL, a 2007 BMW Z4 and several Corvettes from the 1980s and 1990s. Prices on Hemmings began at about $6,500 and reached $50,000 among the listings we saw. Descriptions are written by the dealer, so verify the details of any particular car.

Buying from Humpty Dumpty's

We found no published information on financing, shipping, trade-ins or consignment, and no purchase terms. Hemmings shows the dealer as available by appointment, so call before you visit. For a car you cannot inspect in person, ask for the VIN, title status and a walk-around video, and consider hiring an independent inspector. Our guide on how to buy a classic car walks through those steps.

Reputation

BBB gives the business an A rating. It is not BBB accredited, and BBB shows one complaint that was not resolved. Yelp shows a single review, which praises the cars and trucks as museum quality, but one review is too little to judge by. We found no other review counts. As with any dealer, weigh a specific car on its paperwork and condition. To compare similar cars from other sellers, browse classic cars for sale around the state.

Visiting Humpty Dumpty's Classics

BBB and Hemmings list the dealer at 4023 Sawyer Road, Unit 242, Sarasota, Florida 34233, and the phone number is (941) 923-6430. ClassicCars.com listings are tagged with ZIP code 34241, and BBB shows a second Sarasota address in that ZIP, so confirm the location with the dealer before you drive out. No business hours are published beyond the by-appointment note.