Olson Auto Exchange

Olson Auto Exchange is a dealer on State Road 138 in Stoughton, Wisconsin. Its home page sums up the business in one line: "We sell cars, we buy cars, and we repair classics." The inventory is a short list of older cars and pickups mixed with a few recent vehicles. The dealer is independent and is not affiliated with Classic Cars Arena.

How the business works

Olson sells from its own stock and says it buys cars. The Better Business Bureau profile lists categories that go beyond sales, including vintage auto repair, auto body repair and painting, and auto consignment. Those categories come from the business's own BBB listing, and the dealer's website does not spell out consignment terms or fees, so a seller should ask about commission, timing and who pays for marketing and storage before leaving a car. Our dealer buying guide is aimed at buyers, but the same questions about paperwork and condition apply to a seller handing over a car.

What is on the lot

The inventory page showed 14 vehicles in October 2026, and the dealer's ClassicCars.com page listed nine. The older cars included a 1934 Chevrolet street rod three-window coupe at $36,995, a 1951 GMC 100 step-side pickup described as frame-off at $49,995, a 1954 Ford F-350 at $4,500, a 1964 Ford Thunderbird convertible with a 390 engine at $44,995 and a 1966 Mustang with a 302 crate engine at $39,995. A 1968 Ford Falcon described as custom, a 1970 Chevrolet Monte Carlo, a 1971 Chevrolet C10 and a 1972 Oldsmobile 98 with a 455 V8 were each priced from about $19,995 to $42,995. Alongside those sat a few newer vehicles, such as a 2005 Chrysler Crossfire, a 2018 Jeep Renegade and a 2023 Ford F-150. Several of the cars are modified, so ask what is original and what has been changed.

Buying from Olson

The site lists prices for its cars. It does not publish financing, shipping or inspection terms on the pages we could read. Ask for the title status, service records and any restoration receipts, and consider an independent inspection for anything modified. Confirm a car is still available before you drive out.

Reputation

The BBB shows an A+ rating for Olson Auto Exchange, although the business is not BBB accredited. The profile lists a business start date of July 1977, which is a registration-type date, so we do not give it as the dealership's founding year. Review sites also list the business: a Birdeye page shows 72 customer reviews, and another directory reports 4.8 stars from 51 ratings. Treat the counts as a pointer rather than a verdict, and read recent comments before you buy.

Visiting and contact

The address is 3447 State Road 138 W, Stoughton, Wisconsin 53589. The phone number on the dealer's site is (608) 470-7608, and the email is [email protected]. Some directories list a different number, 608-873-5264, so use the one from the website. No hours are published, so call first. For more cars across the state, see more classic cars in Wisconsin.