Classic Gas & Auto

Classic Gas & Auto is a classic muscle car dealer at 9051 Harrison Avenue in Cleves, Ohio, a small town on the Ohio River in the far southwest corner of the state, roughly 20 miles west of downtown Cincinnati. The Better Business Bureau lists the owner as Daniel Pfaffinger and classifies the business as a classic car dealer. Its listings lean toward Chevrolet and Ford muscle cars, including Camaros, Chevelles, Novas, Mustangs and Corvettes.

Who they are

The company's own website could not be opened during research, so most details here come from the BBB, dealer directories and archived copies of the site. Directory sources are inconsistent about the start date. One lists an Ohio incorporation in January 2019 and the BBB file dates to 2021, while another directory gives an earlier establishment year, so this profile does not state a founding year. No company history, owner biography or "about us" story was found on the pages reviewed.

How the business works

Classic Gas & Auto is a dealer that stocks and sells its own cars. Consignment is not advertised anywhere we could find. Its website runs on the Carsforsale.com platform, and a 2025 archived copy shows a banner reading "We want your vehicle!" along with a "Value My Trade" appraisal form and a car-finder request form. So the dealer appears to buy cars and take trade-ins as well as sell them. The same archived pages label some listings with "Video Walkarounds," "Driveway Delivery" and "Virtual Financing," which suggests remote buying is supported, but the terms are not spelled out, so ask what each one includes.

What it sells

The stock is mostly American muscle cars and pony cars from the 1960s and early 1970s. Archived listings included 1969 and 1972 Camaros, several 1970 Chevelles including SS 454 cars, a 1966 and a 1970 Nova, 1965 and 1966 Mustangs, a 1969 Plymouth Road Runner, a GTO convertible and a Corvette. Directory snapshots also mention a Chevrolet Blazer K5, a Dodge Challenger and an occasional motorcycle. A Carsforsale.com directory page describes the dealer's cars as high quality restored vehicles, and the prices seen fit that: listings ran from the high $30,000s into six figures, with Chevelle SS prices from about $61,800 to $122,800 on that page. Inventory turns over, so check current listings. For restored or modified cars, descriptions such as numbers-matching, build quality and engine swaps are worth documenting before you commit.

Buying from Classic Gas & Auto

Buyers contact the dealer by phone or through the contact form on its site. Beyond the labels mentioned above, the pages reviewed do not describe deposits, inspections or shipping, so confirm those details in writing. For a car you cannot see in person, request detailed photos and a walk-around video, ask for the title and any restoration records, and hire an independent inspector. Our guide on how to buy a classic car walks through the usual steps.

Reputation

The BBB lists Classic Gas & Auto with an A+ rating, but the business is not BBB accredited. The BBB page shows one complaint closed in the last three years and no customer reviews. Birdeye shows an unclaimed listing with a rating of about 4.0 stars from 38 reviews. That is a modest public record for a dealer selling cars at these price levels, so the usual advice applies: read recent reviews yourself, ask for references and get an independent inspection before you pay.

Visiting Classic Gas & Auto

The address is 9051 Harrison Avenue, Cleves, Ohio 45002. The dealer's website lists (513) 496-0809, while the BBB shows (513) 615-5755, so try the first number and fall back to the second. Hours were not confirmed on any page we could open, and the business may operate largely by appointment, so call ahead. To compare other options, browse more classic cars in Ohio.