Lady Luck Garage

Lady Luck Garage is a hot rod and classic car dealership in Kelseyville, California. It buys, trades and consigns classic cars and hot rods and sells them from an 8,000 square foot building, a former dealership, on Main Street. It is an independent business and is not affiliated with Classic Cars Arena.

The business and its building

The dealership's website says it was founded in February 2021 and operates from the Norton Motors building, a 101 year old Ford and Dodge dealership. The site names Chuck Sutfin as owner and Lynn Corey as manager. It also advertises event space, and a July 2026 Lake County Features article describes a Cars and Coffee gathering on the first Saturday of each month.

What they sell

The focus is hot rods and traditional American classics. The article says the garage sells hot rods and classics built in 1975 or earlier, though the site includes a few newer cars. In October 2026 the inventory page listed 21 vehicles with asking prices from $14,000 to $76,000. Examples included a 1955 Chevrolet Bel Air restomod at $76,000, a 1968 Camaro restomod at $76,000, a 1972 El Camino with an LS5 454 at $36,000, a 1967 Ford Bronco at $66,000, a 1933 Ford half ton at $55,000, a 1929 Ford Model A at $19,000 and a 1963 Thunderbird at $32,000. Other recent listings included a 1931 Ford Deluxe Coupe, a 1968 Oldsmobile Cutlass 442, a 1950 Oldsmobile 88 and a 1981 Corvette. Prices and stock change, so confirm a car is still available before you travel.

Buying, selling and consigning

The home page describes buying, trading and consignment, including consignment for in-house and internet sales worldwide. Mr. Sutfin told the newsletter that the garage sells classics all over the country and even a few internationally. No commission rate or consignment contract terms are published, so ask for them in writing. Our guide to consigning a classic explains the usual fee structures and what to ask before you sign.

Reputation

We found no BBB profile for Lady Luck Garage. The dealer's Facebook page showed 9,283 followers, and it is listed on Classics on Autotrader and ClassicCars.com, where we saw 10 vehicles. We did not find a rating or review count we could verify, so we do not quote one. With limited outside feedback, do your own checks: confirm the title and VIN, request photos and video, and consider an independent inspection, especially on a restomod or a hot rod with custom work. You can also compare similar cars through California classic cars for sale.

Visiting Lady Luck Garage

The showroom is at 4010 Main Street, Kelseyville, CA 95451. The site lists contact numbers for owner Chuck Sutfin and manager Lynn Corey and says appointments are available if you call ahead. Its pages disagree slightly on hours. Both show Wednesday through Friday from 9 AM to 4 PM, but one lists Saturday from 9 AM to 2 PM and the store hours block lists Saturday and Sunday from 10 AM to 4 PM, with Monday and Tuesday closed. Call (707) 533-7621 before you drive out. The site does not publish an email address.