Cincy Classic Cars, LLC

Cincy Classic Cars, LLC is a small classic car dealer in Milford, Ohio, a suburb east of Cincinnati in Clermont County. The Better Business Bureau lists the business as started in January 2016 and names Dan Gabel as its principal, and the company's website names him as the contact for buyers. It sells a limited number of cars at a time, with a focus on 1970s American muscle such as Pontiac Trans Ams and Chevrolet Camaros.

Who they are

The company's about page describes the owners as enthusiasts who own several classic cars themselves and take them to car shows, cruise-ins, swap meets and auctions, and it says they have won hundreds of trophies. Those are the business's own statements and cannot be checked independently. The site's stated aim is to keep transactions "fair and simple" so that both sides are happy. The website does not give a founding year, so the 2016 date here comes from the BBB file.

How the business works

Cincy Classic Cars sells cars from its own stock. The pages we read do not mention consignment, and they do not describe a program for buying cars from the public or taking trade-ins, so an owner who wants to sell should call and ask before assuming either is on offer. Inventory is small. The dealer's ClassicCars.com page showed four cars, and the company's own site lists a handful of current cars and a "Recently sold" page.

What they sell

The site says it focuses on hand-picked Trans Ams, Firebirds, Z28s, Camaros, Mustangs, Triumphs, Corvettes and other classics, and it favors sound, correct, original cars it calls "drivers" over show queens. In October 2026 the home page listed:

• a 1979 Pontiac Trans Am with a 400 engine and four-speed, described as rotisserie restored, at $52,900
• a 1973 Chevrolet Camaro Z28, described as numbers matching, at $39,900
• a 1973 Chevrolet Nova Custom with a 350 and automatic at $23,900
• a 1979 Pontiac Formula with T-tops at $19,900
• a 2006 Ford Mustang convertible at $23,500

A 1959 MGA was also shown among its new arrivals. Stock turns over, so treat this as a sample of the range. For more choices nearby, see Ohio classic cars for sale.

Buying from Cincy Classic Cars

The dealer-info page on the company's site sets out its terms, and they are worth reading before you commit. Deposits are described as non refundable and as a commitment to buy, and vehicles are sold as is, with no expressed or implied warranties. Because of that, a buyer should look at the car in person or arrange an independent inspection first. Our guide on what to check before you buy covers the questions to ask about title, condition and paperwork.

The company says it ships vehicles throughout the United States and even overseas. It recommends enclosed transport and will help put buyers in touch with independent carriers, but it says it takes no responsibility for the carriers themselves. After payment, a car can stay on site for 15 calendar days at no charge, then the company lists a storage fee of $25 per day.

The company does not offer financing of its own. Its financing page points buyers to four lenders that work with collector cars: J.J. Best Banc and Co., Collector Car Lending Co., Woodside Credit and LightStream. It also notes that a personal bank or credit union is often the best source of a loan. Rates and terms are not published, so compare offers directly.

Reputation

The BBB lists Cincy Classic Cars as not accredited, with an A+ rating, no complaints closed in the past three years and no customer reviews posted. That is a clean file, though a thin one. Public review pages exist for the business on other sites, but we could not confirm a star rating or review count directly, so none is quoted here. Judge the specific car, verify the title and VIN, and get any promise about condition in writing.

Visiting and contact

The dealership is at 940 Lila Ave, Milford, Ohio 45150. The phone number is (513) 256-5543 and the public email address is [email protected]. The website does not publish opening hours, so call ahead before visiting a particular car.