Motorcar Classics

Motorcar Classics is an exotic and collector car dealership at 380 Smith Street in Farmingdale, New York. It describes itself as a licensed New York State dealer that sells, trades and consigns vintage and late-model high-line, exotic and collectible cars, and it also runs a car storage business. It is independent and is not affiliated with Classic Cars Arena.

What kind of dealer it is

The company's own figures point to a large operation. It says it has more than 200 vehicles in inventory and over 80,000 square feet of showroom and warehouse space, and it calls itself one of the largest and highest rated exotic and classic dealerships in the country. Those are its own claims. Its about page names Porsche, Ferrari, Lamborghini, Aston Martin, Bentley, Rolls-Royce, Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Chevrolet, and says its American cars include stock and modified examples from the 1930s to recent limited-edition performance models. Buyers looking only for vintage cars should expect plenty of modern exotics mixed in.

What it sells

In early October 2026, the dealer's listings on classic.com included a 1962 Chevrolet Corvette 283 fuel-injected convertible and a 1970 Manx, alongside late-model Ferraris. ClassicCars.com showed roughly 140 of its listings at that time. Check availability and current pricing with the dealer directly.

Consignment, with published terms

Motorcar Classics publishes consignment terms. It says there are no upfront fees and that its consignment percentage is typically 5 percent or a $3,000 minimum, depending on the value of the vehicle. It says consigned cars are stored in its showroom, hand washed, professionally photographed and advertised on its own site and third-party sites such as Cars.com, CarGurus, Hemmings and Autotrader. Our consignment guide explains how to compare these terms with other dealers.

Storage and other services

• Storage: monthly or year-round, in what the company describes as insured, enclosed and climate-controlled space across two locations.
• Concierge services: service maintenance, detailing and concours preparation, according to its storage page.
• Shipping: it says it ships cars nationwide and worldwide.
• Remote buying help: the site says it will help with due diligence, including a personal or independent inspection, and a buyer's review on the site mentions help with financing.

Reputation

The Better Business Bureau lists Motorcar Classics with an A+ rating, but the business is not BBB accredited. The profile says it has been in business about ten years. We did not read a complaint count, so check the BBB page for the current figure. The home page carries about 17 customer comments covering purchases, sales and storage, but the business selected them. As with any large dealer, get the VIN, title and condition report in writing, and for a car far away consider an independent inspection.

Visiting Motorcar Classics

The dealership is at 380 Smith Street, Farmingdale, NY 11735, and its sales number is 631-779-6200. The site lists hours of Monday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 7 p.m., Saturday, 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., and Sunday by appointment. To see how other sellers compare, browse classic cars for sale around the state.