Otto Motorcars LLC

Otto Motorcars is a small Sarasota business that brokers the sale of exotic, luxury and collector cars, with a strong lean toward European marques. It is run by Jurgen Otto and does not work like a conventional dealership: the cars it markets usually belong to their owners until the moment of sale, and the buyer pays the seller directly. Florida state records show the company was registered as a limited liability company in 2012, and it receives visitors by appointment only.

Who runs Otto Motorcars

The company is built around its owner. Its website says Jurgen Otto has more than 35 years of experience in the automobile industry and singles out his work with the Mercedes-Benz 300 (W188) and 600 (W100) models, twelve-cylinder Ferraris and air-cooled Porsches. Otto Motorcars LLC was filed with the Florida Division of Corporations on March 23, 2012, and Otto is listed as its manager. A report on the cars Hagerty gathered for its 2021 "Bull Market" display at Road America named Otto, of Otto Motorcars in Sarasota, as the owner of the Ferrari Testarossa in that group.

A broker, not a showroom dealer

Otto Motorcars describes its main service as exotic and luxury car consignment, but the way it handles a sale is closer to brokerage. In the company's words, "all sales are handled similar to a real estate transaction." The buyer purchases directly from the owner, Otto Motorcars handles the marketing and the negotiation, and payment goes from the buyer to the seller. For buyers, that means the title and the funds move between private parties, with the broker acting as go-between. For sellers, it means the car stays in their name until it is sold. Anyone curious about the alternatives can read how classic car consignment works at a traditional consignment dealer.

What Otto Motorcars sells

The company lists its specialties as Ferrari, Porsche, classic Mercedes-Benz, classic BMW and British cars such as Aston Martin, Rolls-Royce, Bentley and McLaren. Inventory is small and changes car by car. In early October 2026 the website offered:

• a 1965 Porsche 356 SC Cabriolet at $215,500;
• a 1970 Mercedes-Benz 300 SEL 6.3 at $73,500;
• a 1964 Pontiac LeMans GTO with a factory four-speed and factory air conditioning at $127,500;
• a 1950s gas pump restored in Ferrari livery at $12,500.

A 1990 BMW Z1 and a 2002 BMW Z8 roadster were listed as coming soon. The company's sold page shows the kind of cars it has handled before, including a 1992 Ferrari 512 TR, a 2003 Ferrari 575M Maranello, several Ferrari 308s, a 1954 Jaguar XK 120 SE roadster, a 1968 Mercedes-Benz 600 SWB, several BMW Z8s, modern Porsches and a pair of prewar hot rods.

Collection management and accessories

Beyond brokerage, the site has a collection management section that lists repair and service management work on a 1962 Mercedes-Benz 300SL Roadster, a 1953 Mercedes-Benz 300S Cabriolet, a Ferrari Daytona and a Ferrari 275 GTB. The company does not describe this service in detail, so owners should ask what it covers. A separate accessories page offers handcrafted engine tables, restored gas station pumps and fitted luggage sets for Ferraris.

Buying through Otto Motorcars

The website does not publish financing, shipping or inspection arrangements. Because the purchase is made directly from the owner, buyers should confirm who holds the title, make sure any payment goes to the person named on it, and get the agreed terms in writing. For high-value European cars, an independent pre-purchase inspection by a marque specialist and a check of service records are worth the cost. The company's own advice to buyers is to "always buy the best car you can afford." To compare prices before you call, browse classic cars for sale around the state.

Reputation

Otto Motorcars has been registered in Florida since 2012 and its website shows a steady record of sold cars. We did not find a Better Business Bureau profile and did not see review counts on any platform we could check, so there is no public rating to report. As with any broker, the useful checks are the car's paperwork, the title holder and an independent inspection.

Visiting and contact

Otto Motorcars LLC is at 2131 Global Court, Sarasota, Florida 34240. Its contact page states that visits are by appointment only. The phone number is 941-356-4626, and the website has a contact form rather than a public email address.